Reporters' Roundtable Podcast: A tablet future?
Next year will probably see new tablet computers from Apple and maybe even Microsoft. What do these companies know that our panel does not? Featuring Ryan Block and Harry McCracken.
Listen now: Download today's podcast
Subscribe with iTunes (audio)
Subscribe with iTunes (video)
Subscribe with RSS (audio)
Subscribe with RSS (video)
Reporters Roundtable # 5: Tablets' uncertain future
It's the obligatory Tablets edition of the Roundtable, this time with even more great and smart tech journalist entrepreneurs from Gdgt (Ryan Block) and Technologizer (Harry McCracken). Watch or listen for the content. Click to the full story to see the notes we used when recording.
Intros/news recap
Welcome to Reporters Roundtable, CNET's deep dive into a burning tech topic each week. Today, we're talking about tablet computers. Everyone is expecting Apple to roll out a tablet, or slate, or e-book, or whatever you call it, next year. Rumors are that the device will sell in the $600-to-$800 price range. And recently, we've seen videos of the Microsoft Courier interface, Microsoft's secret tablet project. It's obviously not as secret as Apple's.
Then, of course, there's the unreleased CrunchPad, instigated by TechCrunch founder Michael Arrington. Will it join the legion of failed tablet and slate computers released? Can it compete with offerings from Microsoft and Apple? And why don't we have tablets today? Will we finally get them next year? That's what we're discussing today, with two special guests:
First, Ryan Block, co-founder of the consumer tech community site Gdgt. Ryan was editor of the Engadget blog before Gdgt. He knows his Apple rumors.
We also have Harry McCracken, editor and founder of the new tech blog Technologizer. Before launching that site, Harry served as editor in chief of PC World magazine.
Talking points
First up: What and when?
Do consumers really want tablets?
What is a tablet? A computer without a pen? A TV? A book reader?
Which barriers need to fall: price, performance, software?
Brad Stone of The New York Times gives 5 reasons tablets have flopped:
- Commitment
- Technology
- Input systems
- Price
- Software
- What's the right size?
- What about the folding concept (from Microsoft)?
- If they're as big as laptops, what will be their competitive appeal?
- Newton
- Palm
- Momenta
- Windows tablets
- Ultramobile PCs, aka UMPCs, in general (Oqo in particular)
- Apple
- Microsoft Courier
- Crunchpad
- Kindle
What are the technological blockers?
What kind of operating system will be prevalent for tablets? Phone or PC?
Talk about form factors:
Let's look at successes or failures that could be illustrative:
Handicapping...let's discuss
From readers
----------------
@Rafe do you (the panel) think tablets are computing's version of the video telephone? [via twitter - mors-d]
----------------
Dave from Thunder Bay, Ontario, here, in the middle of the continent and the middle of nowhere.
Here's something I'd like to see and a lot of families would make use of: The centre of the modern family is the big calendar on the fridge with illegible appointments on it. What I want is a screen that goes on the fridge or the wall that will wirelessly sync with all my family's Google calendars with a touch screen to easily enter events. What I don't want is a full-blown tablet PC. Is there anything out there that fits this description?
David Hawkins
----------------
Wrap
Thanks for joining us, Harry and Ryan. Thanks also to Lynn Fu, our producer.
Obligatory pimping: Be sure to visit Ggdt and Technologizer.
Thanks for listening to Reporters Roundtable. We're on live each Friday at 1 p.m. PT at live.cnet.com.
Next time: A fantastic show! So fantastic that I don't know what it'll be yet. Got ideas? Send them to our new e-mail address: roundtable@cnet.com.
Thanks!
Related reading
Harry McCracken, Technologizer: Archos' Android 5 Tablet: It Isn't a PC (or is It?)
Rafe Needleman, CNET: Why consumers won't buy tablets
Photos via Gizmodo: The new Microsoft tablet
Jason Hiner, Tech Republic: A history of the elusive Apple tablet, in links
Brad Stone, The New York Times: Why Have Tablets Flopped? Here Are Five Reasons
Popular Mechanics: "10 Most Brilliant Products of 2009" includes CrunchPad Tablet
Rafe Needleman writes about start-ups, new technologies, and Web 2.0 products, as editor of CNET's Webware. E-mail Rafe.
Rafe Needleman is editor of CNET's Webware. He's been covering technology since 1988, and has interviewed thousands of tech execs. He blogs at 
And unlike your favorite US corporations, Archos has actually shown the tablets, released them on the real market at very affordable prices.
You can buy Archos's last couple of years WiFi Internet Media Tablets for $100-$155 for 4.8" and 4.3" screen sizes and 800x480 resolutions.
Unlike your bloatware US corporations, Archos Windows 7 tablet is released at affordable $499.
Also, camera mobile phones have been built-in cheap smartphones in Europe and Asia for more than 6 years. I bought a Motorola A920 for $50 and $30 monthly UMTS contracts 6 years ago that still does great video-conferencing quality right there on the mobile phone.
The reason you don't have video conferencing in the US, is not because your lazy US corporation monopolies don't know how to make them, it's because your monopolistic carriers block any 3G applications on cell phones that may use too much of their bandwidth,
Honestly, I was under the impression that most computers didn't have pens. =/
-
by oddzerver
October 26, 2009 1:42 PM PDT
- I also want a tablet. I have wanted one for years. I have never seen a tablet in any store. Maybe next year I will send in $1500+ for a device I have not touched, but as you state, there is no compelling reason to do so. I would also like it to be my phone. If I carry it around, I see no reason why it cannot host a bluetooth headset. Again, I have never heard this discussed before in any tablet forum. I am a boomer, and I work in technology and try to keep up with trends.
-
Like this
Reply to this comment
-
(5 Comments)