• On MovieTome: The 10 worst movies of 2009 so far!
January 27, 2009 3:51 PM PST

The Real Deal 146: The file frontier--home media management

by Tom Merritt
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 4 comments

How do you share, store, and manage all those photos, MP3s, videos, and other stuff? There's no perfect way, but we discuss some options.
Listen now: Download today's podcast


First, props to gknee's husband for the title of this episode. He even made art! Let's set the table with this e-mail.

************ Love the topic this week.

We have many computers in our house and it is a constant struggle to keep all of our photos, videos, music, and movies organized.

The closest I’ve come so far has been to use a NAS drive to store our photos and home movies (recorded with our digital camera). I have each computer mount the NAS when they start up on the network. Then, we use Picasa and make sure to have it index the folders on the NAS drive.

The problem is that my no-tech wife uploads photos and videos from our camera onto her computer in seemingly random folders instead of saving them to the network drive (no matter how many times I remind her). So, I have to make sure to copy all of the files from her computer to the NAS every once in a while.

As for our movies, I purchased an external SATA hard drive to expand our Tivo’s storage capacity, then I ripped all of our DVDs (we don’t own many) with DVD Shrink and transferred the movies to the Tivo using a Tivo Desktop replacement program called pyTivo. It’s so much nicer to have our movies on the Tivo already. Dealing with a DVD player in this day and age is a pain.

Our music files are scattered all over the f&^%$^% place.

I’m very interested in hearing what the members of the township of Deal come up with.

Much respect, MC Fisticuffs.

********

The problems: Networking is wonky, Windows to Mac issues, Work domains on home system

Syncing: How do you get just the photos, music, and other files you want on your machine without keeping a copy of everything in existence?

The cloud: Flickr, LaLa?, Picasa, Google Docs. This isn't helping. It makes it more of a mess. If you paid for S3 it would be expensive.

The solutions: NAS attached to your home network accessible from the Internet, Still has issues

The ideal: Here's what we want the companies to do.

Comments on Windows 7 epidode:

Hi Rafe, Tom, I have been running Windows 7 as my primary OS for the past few days and it has been working out quite well for me. The Windows+Tab key command that cycles through the open windows is much smoother. Some programs work faster, and I love the new Snipping Tool.

I wonder why they did not simply push this as Vista SP2. It would have saved Vista's name and it would have followed an established trend: Third time's the charm. - didibanner


fleddyx Rafe mentioned he uses an extension/add-in/program allowing him to dock and lock running programs to various positions on his screen/monitor. Can he share the name of the program? What others might I try?

Comment on password episode

7-zip (the best compression/archive manager for Windows) has an option to make archives with 256 bit AES encryption. It's a really good option for encrypting individual files and folders. Plus, when installed, it puts a 7-zip option on your context menu, so putting files/folders in an archive only takes a few clicks. It comes in a portable version (portableapps.com <http://portableapps.com> ) which is also open-source and freeware, so you can handle your archives on the go. I always put important data in an encrypted 7-zip archive before emailing it to myself.

Tony

Next episode - Shortcuts! Send us yours!

realdeal@cnet.com

forums.cnet.com

Recent posts from The Real Deal Podcast
The Real Deal 188: Tech Turkeys
The Real Deal 187: Should you buy that warranty?
The Real Deal 186: Essential software for a new PC (or Mac)
The Real Deal 185: Road test: Windows 7
The Real Deal 184: Who should own the Internet
The Real Deal 183: All about Windows 7
The Real Deal 182: All questions episode
The Real Deal 181: Steve Jobs
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (4 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by lundp_dotmac January 28, 2009 4:54 AM PST
Is the HP Media Smart device a close match to what you are looking for in a NAS media storage device?
Reply to this comment
by countrylad63 January 28, 2009 9:48 AM PST
I have a nas Device NexStar Lx to which both my pc and mac use. I map the drive on the pc and it just shows up on the mac.

I just ordered this device, pogoplug.com, and hope to get on the beta testing. Access any usb hardrive over your network or the internet

Tom
Reply to this comment
by DougInKY January 31, 2009 5:31 PM PST
You all have been asking for a file solution for a mixed Windows, Mac household. I need an answer for the Windows (wife), Mac (my laptop) and Linux (my Desktop) household. Not trying to make things more complicated but there has to be an answer out there.
Reply to this comment
by didibanner February 1, 2009 7:01 PM PST
Hey Rafe, Tom,
Thanks for reading my message about Windows 7 :)

This might not have anything to do with anything but on Saturday, I noticed that all my Google ended up giving "Harmful Website" results.
I was a little bit surprised by how quickly I switched to using yahoo as my primary search engine when this happened. And it was not that bad.
If this is representative of the general public, I guess Google's hold on us is a little more tenuous than we might have thought.

Love the show,
Didi
Reply to this comment
(4 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
Subscribe to The Real Deal podcast

Subscribe to the audio podcast via RSS
Subscribe to the video podcast via RSS

Subscribe to the audio podcast via iTunes
Subscribe to the video podcast via iTunes

advertisement

About The Real Deal Podcast

The knowledge you need isn't always esoteric; sometimes it's just hard to find. The Real Deal gives you access to secrets and info that will help you master the confusing world of technology. Every Tuesday Tom and Rafe take on a new topic as well as taking your e-mail.

Send Tom and Rafe e-mail at realdeal@cnet.com or call them at 1-877-600-2638 (CNET).


Add this feed to your online news reader

The Real Deal Podcast topics

More on The Real Deal
The Real Deal forum
The Real Deal live stream (Tuesdays, 3:00pm PST)
Webware
CNET Forums
CNET Online courses
CNET TV blog
Meet The Real Deal hosts
Tom Merritt Tom Merritt appears on CNET TV and loves to dive into technology and help consumers fight fear, uncertainty, and doubt with technology. See profile
Rafe Needleman Rafe Needleman is editor of Webware.com, CNET's blog about Web applications. He lives to discover great new online apps – and to rip apart bad ones. See profile
Digital Dispatch newsletter
Digital Dispatch newsletter Delivered daily, our flagship newsletter highlights the best and latest at CNET. Subscribe free

Podroll
When you're not listening to The Real Deal, here's some other great podcasts to try.
Andy Melton's The Weekly Tech Review
Diggnation
This WEEK in TECH
Galacticast
Ask a Ninja
Tom's Buzz Out Loud video
Other CNET podcasts