• On BNET: Vote: How will Apple blow it?
February 28, 2008 5:00 AM PST

Stink-free compost right in the kitchen

by Jennifer Guevin
NatureMill automated indoor composter

NatureMill's automated composter can fit in a regular kitchen cabinet.

(Credit: NatureMill)

The quest to make kitchens around the country more eco-friendly just got a little easier. NatureMill, a San Francisco-based company founded by an MIT grad in 2004, is adding to its lineup of indoor automatic composters.

NatureMill's composters speed up the process of composting by heating, mixing, and aerating the waste that gets put into it. After two weeks, fresh food waste can be turned into nutrient-rich fertilizer for the garden, according to the company. They're small enough to fit into a regular kitchen cabinet (20 inches long by 12 inches wide by 20 inches high), and to reduce the stink, air is forced through a carbon filter when it gets sucked in to oxygenate the waste.

The regular "Plus" model will run you $299 and can process up to 120 pounds of waste per month. And although it's small enough that it could probably fit in a smaller apartment kitchen, it's only useful if you've got a yard in which to use the compost you make. One batch of compost is good for 10 - 40 square feet, according to the company, so you'll need to have a big enough yard to accommodate a fair amount of fertilizer. For people considering setting up a more traditional compost bin, though, the NatureMill system can be kept inside the house to reduce the need to take out kitchen waste so often; used outside, it works faster than passive composting and doesn't require the same kind of attention to acidity, temperature, and aeration that so-called managed composting does. And the company says the composters will hold up in the rain and snow.

NatureMill pet-friendly composter

Don't look so guilty, little one. One pup's trash is another man's tulips.

(Credit: NatureMill)

NatureMill also makes a professional version that's intended for heavier use. It comes with a foot pedal for hands-free operation, has components made of stainless steel, and can be switched into vacation mode for times when the kitchen is closed. There's even a version for pet owners, which can accept pet and kitchen waste. The pet-friendly composter has its limits though; NatureMill does not recommend it for use with horses or other large animals. Both of those models go for $399.

For those wondering about the trade-off in power usage, the company says it consumes less energy than a standard night-light and costs about 50 cents per month to run.

Jennifer Guevin is assistant managing editor of CNET News. She focuses on science and green tech. But she also makes the occasional contribution to CNET's kitchen gadgets blog or writes about the latest Web distraction. Once a week, she takes the mic as host of CNET's Daily News Podcast. E-mail Jennifer.
Recent posts from Appliances & Kitchen Gadgets
Popcorn and nuts find harmony in one appliance
Scale becomes part of kitchen decor
Microwave mug cakes for single-serving snacks
Wake to a hot cup of coffee
Solve the trash problem you didn't know you had
It's never too late for frozen pops
A cool new cooktop concept
Fall back--with a kitchen range hood
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (8 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by Amazed62 February 28, 2008 10:33 AM PST
Like the i-phone and blue tooth headsets another triumph of technology over common sense.
Reply to this comment
by sandor_f February 28, 2008 11:07 AM PST
Try composting any other way in a 3rd floor walk up with only roof top and fire escape access. My potted veggies and herbs will love an organic fertilizer, and my decrease in trash weight each week, and the decrease in used diesel fuel, will easily make up for the 5 kwh of electricity this device uses a month.

25% of the US's waste is biodegradable matter that could make excellent compost, instead it is buried in an anaerobic landfill where it wont break down for decades. 1/2 the world lives in urban areas, and many of those people (myself included) have no access to actual soil where we could have a typical compost pile.
by gerrrg February 28, 2008 11:10 AM PST
photoshopped dogs always look better when they're sized appropriately.
Reply to this comment
by tony_plow March 16, 2009 8:58 PM PDT
DO NOT BUY THIS ITEM!!!

Every negative post (over many websites, here, amazon ...) I have read is exactly what has happened to ours. Further there is no such thing as accountability nor customer service with these people. I am convinced that anyone telling you that it works or to read the directions works for nature mill. Before disregarding this comment take a look at their rating with the better business bureau, I?ll make it easy; http://www.bbb.org/greater-san-francisco/business-reviews/garbage-disposal-equipment-industrial-and-commercial/nature-mill-incorporated-in-san-francisco-ca-77307 This is a product of poor design and awful quality .They will take zero responsibility for it not working and keep throwing parts in the mail telling us this will fix the problem (different part each of the 3 x's,Yes,THREE TIMES!!!) Each time it has been serviced (by us) it has jammed within 10 min of plugging it in. And last but not least the smell is awful!!! The 1st 2 times it was ok, this third time is smells like a Styrofoam cooler (which this product actually is made of, Styrofoam) that has rotten veggies in it baking in the sun, why you might ask? Because that is what this product is, a $300 Styrofoam cooler with a heater in it and pieces of tin nailed (yes actually nailed with a wood nail to Styrofoam) to it.
Reply to this comment
by snitily March 31, 2009 11:22 AM PDT
I've had one of these for a year. It works to make compost when the unit is working. And it does it well. However, my first unit lasted three months before breaking. The company sent me a new one, but it broke in about three months as well. Both times the units broke. They stopped automatically opening the trap door to dump the finished product, which meant to make it work I had to manually remove the compost from the machine. The second unit now has broken beyond usage now after six months running. I have given up on the product. I don't want another one.

More than the fragility of it, the thing truly stinks. A terrible stench comes from it. I grew up on a cattle farm and we had pigs from time to time, but even I cannot stand the smell. It drips juice which then molds in the tray and STINKS! Dumping it is an awful messy chore. Actually dumping the compost by hand is an awful messy chore. I'm so disappointed because the thing had really potential, but I've given it a year of babysitting and care and I'm over the mess. Moving on to other options.
Reply to this comment
by biggardenguy April 11, 2009 3:05 PM PDT
We have one of these at work. It is really great. It took our office manager a couple weeks to set it up and get the "cultures " going. Ever since then we all just dump our lunchtime scraps in there and it just goes down to almost nothing. All the coffee grounds and tea bags go right in. We are trying to get our office to zero waste, which means everything has to be recycled or composted. We are getting close!

It is especially enjoyable to clean out the lunch room fridge at the end of each week (that is my job) and anything that isn't claimed goes into the composter. By Monday it is basically dirt. Really great. It jams sometimes so be careful to not overload it.
Reply to this comment
by tomasjmm June 8, 2009 12:27 PM PDT
I've been in a year long struggle to get this thing replaced / fixed.
Not only did this thing break in the first few months, the "Customer Service" will do absolutely EVERYTHING to avoid replacing the machine -- including having the customer do his/her OWN tedious repairs. Their version of troubleshooting the problem is to send you part after part, with instructions on how to fix the thing yourself. I consider myself a handy person, but I sympathize with those who do not have the tools nor are capable enough to make their own product repairs. THIS IS NOT OUR RESPONSIBILITY. (I purchased this for my parents, who are in their late-sixties, and it saddens me to think of them trying to do such meticulous repairs on their own.) And to boot, this is all happening under the 5-YEAR extended warranty which I paid extra for.

From what I understand, they have fixed the first-generation problems.
But for all of us who supported them at the beginning, there is no service, nor is there any accountability for a faulty product.
Reply to this comment
by tomlauter August 3, 2009 3:20 PM PDT
I have one of the newer models (the XE version) and it is such a joy! I can't believe how fast it makes the compost. It smells very sweet and earthy like sourdough bread, but only when you open the lid. The rest of the time it is odorless and almost silent. I strongly recommend this product for anyone who gardens, or for anyone who cares about the environment. Stop trashing our planet and compost already!
Reply to this comment
(8 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

About Appliances & Kitchen Gadgets

Having transformed the den and the living room, technology is about to revolutionize the kitchen and even the laundry room. Manufacturers are increasingly cramming silicon into everything from refrigerators to spoons, and you can count on CNET's technology experience to follow and explain these trends. In this blog, you'll find the good, the bad, the priceless, the useless, and everything that fits in between, brought to you by a team of culinary professionals and technology experts from CNET and its network of bloggers.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Appliances & Kitchen Gadgets topics