• On GameSpot: Wii Fit tells 10-year-old she's fat
May 22, 2008 12:18 PM PDT

Sorry, but Apple can't do everything right

Posted by Don Reisinger
  • Font size
  • Print

Some people want us to believe that Apple doesn't do anything wrong. In fact, those same people usually believe that each and every product Apple has ever created has easily surpassed the quality and beauty of all of its competitors. Surely they would like you to forget the Apple Newton and the '90s, and invariably they'll forget that the company's Apple TV is hardly a success.

But alas, this is not meant to be an indictment of Apple or its cult-like following. Instead, it's an indictment on how ludicrous some of the claims flying around Apple truly are. How many times are we forced to endure the inexcusable lack of common sense as it pertains to Apple's future before someone stands up and says that enough is enough?

And while I may expect that sort of reaction from some of the Mac faithful, I certainly wouldn't expect it from a reputable firm. But after reading through the Forrester Research speculation piece, I can't help but wonder what the analysts were thinking. Do they honestly believe that a company that has gone out of its way to develop elite products will really release a picture frame?

Steve Jobs may be good, but he's not that good.

Now, before I get into the speculation, I should say that Forrester is guessing what Apple may have up its sleeve going forward and it did present a roadmap that would take it out to 2013. But if you apply logic to some of its predictions, I seriously doubt even the most outrageous Apple zealot will agree with most of them.

The great photo frame

Huh? They can't be serious, right? An Apple photo frame? Gee, now that sounds like something that Steve Jobs would release. Let's see -- iPhone, iPod, MacBook Pro, Apple TV, digital photo frame?

Forrester thinks it'll connect to iPhoto or other online image services and could be a staple in your living room. I think Forrester is totally off its rocker.

Wake up with Apple!

Picture yourself snoozing in your Batman PJs. Now picture yourself being woken up by the voice of Steve Jobs himself thanks to Apple clock radio. Doesn't that sound simply wonderful?

According to Forrester, the Apple clock radio will connect to iTunes and before you know it, you'll be woken up to one of the songs in your library. Sounds too much like an alarm clock with an iPod dock to me. My guess? No way.

A sophisticated remote control

This is probably one of the few that makes any sense. Forrester thinks Apple may want to release a sophisticated remote control that lets you walk around the house and flip through your iTunes library on the fly. According to the company, it can see it becoming a staple in just about any room and should connect to your home network. Even better, it'll play shows, movies, or songs through Apple-branded speakers.

Some may say that Apple won't want to get into this game because of its penchant for more simple products, but I think it makes some sense. The universal remote control business is booming and companies like Logitech are leading the charge with highly sophisticated products that ooze elegance. And if you ask me, that's exactly what Apple is best at.

I don't think we can debate the fact that Apple wants to control the living room, but I'm not sure it really wants to control every facet of it. Does it really want to release a picture frame? Is an alarm clock really necessary for it to become an even greater presence in the industry?

I don't think so.

Apple's vision for the future is rooted in its belief that if it can strategically guard against any outside intrusion by competitors and create a compelling set of products that won't impede its ability to maintain its status as one of the elite members in the industry. If it loses those two attributes, it's left with nothing more than a bloated product line with too many choices and not enough benefits.

Apple simply can't do everything right. And although some may want to believe that it can, rest assured that it's good at creating products that people actually want; not devices that we don't care about.

For more on what Don is up to, follow him on Twitter!

Don Reisinger is a technology columnist who has written about everything from HDTVs to computers to Flowbee Haircut Systems. Don is a member of the CNET Blog Network, and posts at The Digital Home. He is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.

Recent posts from The Digital Home
Should we stop the sale of used video games?
Bat and ball replaced by Web and games?
Why won't Sony or Microsoft admit Nintendo is a competitor?
Why I'm shopping on Black Friday this year
The Digital Home Video: Why you should use Chrome
The Digital Home 42: Should you shop on eBay?
Should parents police their children more aggressively?
The Digital Home Video: Violent video games don't cause violence!
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 65 comments
by Aelwrath May 22, 2008 4:36 PM PDT
"Huh? They can't be serious, right? An Apple photo frame? Gee, now that sounds like something that Steve Jobs would release. Let's see -- iPhone, iPod, MacBook Pro, Apple TV, digital photo frame?

Forrester thinks it'll connect to iPhoto or other online image services and could be a staple in your living room. I think Forrester is totally off its rocker."



While you're correct that analyst predictions like this are almost never correct, you might want to defend your reasoning with, oh, I don't know.... ANYTHING. This is the epitome of declining journalistic standards at Cnet....
Reply to this comment
by bgavinw May 22, 2008 5:25 PM PDT
Uhh.. Apple Universal Remote.. yeah not too hard to figure out .. it's called the iPhone / iPod touch connected to an Apple TV, just like any mac can make a universal remote using an Apple TV.
Reply to this comment
by Aspyr May 22, 2008 6:51 PM PDT
Steve Jobs (may) be good?!?

Just-another-mac-hater who is trying in vain to find something he can criticize Apple about... and yes I saw through your disingenuous offerings of praise.
Reply to this comment
by jragosta May 22, 2008 7:01 PM PDT
Why does Cnet allow these idiots to make stupid strawman arguments? For pete's sake - who says all Apple products are perfect or that Apple can never do anything wrong. I defy the author to find a single person who believes that (other than Artie McStrawman, of course).
Reply to this comment
by mikeohanlon May 22, 2008 7:08 PM PDT
The problem here is that the writer is looking at this and expecting the "norm" in how these products are developed. He's correct in that Apple is unlikely to do a frame or an alarm clock. However, a single digital product, flashy enough to be displayed anywhere in the house and which acts as an alarm clock, music player, video player, calendar, note board, scheduler etc., all the while streaming media from the household media centre is something that I would say Steve J. is quite capable of bringing to market.
Mike
Reply to this comment
by jjbraunius May 22, 2008 8:32 PM PDT
well at least they're trying to lead with some innovation instead of releasing a broken operating system (Vista) and then cutting off support to their older product just so that people will buy it.
Reply to this comment
by dogboi May 22, 2008 9:58 PM PDT
I'm a recent Mac convert, but sometimes, I wish I wasn't. Not because it's a bad product. My MacBook is probably the best machine I've ever owned that I didn't build myself. It's the damn cult-like behavior surrounding many (and it's many, not most) Mac users that bothers me. You're basically criticizing the Forrester Speculative report here, and yet, you're called an Apple Hater. Sorry, that's just creepy.

I left the PC world because if Vista is the future of PC's, I want no part of it. By the same token, if I have to shave an apple symbol in the back of my head just because I own a MacBook and iPod, I'll bail in a heartbeat (and I'm exaggerating, of course.) Sometimes it feels that in order to be an owner of an Apple product, you're expected to give up all thought and reason in order to expend energy praising Steve Jobs and the Mighty Apple Empire. Sorry, not my scene. The Mac is a TOOL. It's an elegant tool, but it's still a tool.

The remote idea is an interesting one. I see something like the harmony one, but with no physical buttons at all. The iPod Touch interface would be perfect for a universal remote. I think digital photo frames are pretty silly actually, so I really have no opinion on that except to say, Apple or no, I'd never buy it. The alarm clock is the dumbest thing I've ever heard in my entire life. I own an iPod speaker dock and I purposely stayed away from the alarm clock docks because the speakers generally suck on those devices, in my experience. But an Apple Alarm clock? What's next, Apple pill boxes that remind you to take your pills? Apple bookshelves that recommend a new book for you to read based on what you pull off the shelves? An Apple pantry that automatically updates your shopping list (stored on your mac, of course)? See, I can predict silly Apple products too Forrester. Anyone can. Doesn't take research money to make claims about Apple's future product line. The fact is, in five years, we'll all be totally off the mark. Who predicted the iPod? The iPhone? No one. We can't predict the next innovation. We can speculate, but we'll never be on target.

Personally, I'm waiting for my iShoe. It can power my iPod while I walk. Yeah, that's the ticket.
Reply to this comment
by gianpo June 1, 2008 2:03 AM PDT
He's called an apple hater because the whole first paragraph is saying how mac fans are crazy then goes on to talk about a forrester report that has no berring on apple fans. The report just shows how dumb forrester is not mac fans.
by bjlevine May 22, 2008 10:11 PM PDT
Don,
It's amazing how tortuous your logic has to be in order to spin this tale of assumptions and givens and "everybody knows".

Go back to your hole, troll.
Reply to this comment
by ecotopian--2008 May 22, 2008 10:25 PM PDT
I can't believe CNET publishes this drivel. Why do you bother?
Reply to this comment
by imdylbert May 23, 2008 5:59 AM PDT
Wow. There are some really vicious attacks on Don here. That's uncalled for. You people are incredibly rude. Why do you feel the need to cut somebody down like that?

I definitely have to agree with the logic of the stupidity of the photo frame and alarm clock. There's just no way. But i have a feeling the equivalent of the remote control will probably be appearing in the next few weeks when the App store appears. Somebody will write a universal remote control app for the iTouch and the iPhone. An interface such as those two devices have is just begging to be used that way.
Reply to this comment
by rcrusoe May 23, 2008 6:20 AM PDT
Guys, lighten up. It looks like Don is just pulling a "Dvorak" and baiting Mac bigots (not users / lovers, etc) for clicks. Given Apple's unbelievable success in recent years this is to be expected. Besides, you gotta admit, the odds of an Apple picture frame are even less than those of meeting someone who owns a Zune.
Reply to this comment
by americanone May 23, 2008 10:10 AM PDT
I guess we are running out of things to write about....I don't disagree just think there are bigger stories. I any standing up should be done it should be over the disaster we call Vista.
Reply to this comment
by Boomstickedition May 31, 2008 1:27 PM PDT
Lol what does vista have to do with this article? I guess some people just want to hate for the sake of hating.
by mik3cap May 23, 2008 10:18 AM PDT
The digital photoframe is ridiculous - BUT... a multi-touch "whiteboard" would be fantastic. A thin monitor that hangs on your wall that can display:

- your photos
- your Calendar
- your videos
- web browse

And would also recognize your handwriting and translate it into text and save your drawings.

Now THAT would be something. All the functionality and architecture of an iPhone, synced up with all your other Apple products, but just on your wall or your desk as a larger, touch sensitive display.
Reply to this comment
by Thomas, David May 23, 2008 10:18 AM PDT
Immature, twisted, and no value. It appears your post, is more like some sort of lash back.
Reply to this comment
by Thomas, David May 23, 2008 10:20 AM PDT
Not to the commenters, my post is about the writer.
by Javamav May 23, 2008 10:44 AM PDT
Sheesh, I know the economy is bad, but come on Cnet! You can afford to hire an actual journalist. This is exactly the reason I only come to this site about once every other week now. This article is the most ridiculous thing I have ever read! Don, try including a few facts. I would even settle for something even remotely informative at this point. I am not going to blast back with an argument as to why I think Apple is superior to the PC or Mac user's "cult like" personality because that would be feeding into this absolutely crappy article even further. But I will say this Don, and this is specifically aimed at you as a journalist. With what you wrote, and how you wrote it, you sound like some 13 year old kid sitting in his mom's basement throwing a tantrum because some Mac user just kicked your butt in World of Warcraft, and now you are looking to take it out on the entire Mac community. Well, I have news for you Don. There is a big bright world out there for you to explore in. You should turn off the WoW for a little while and go check it out. Who knows, maybe you can learn how to be a real journalist while you are at it. I came to Cnet looking for tech news and this is the crap I find. Time to find a new source I guess. Just so you know Don, you could have said the same thing of Microsoft and I still would have commented like this. Best of luck to you as a journalist, I think you will need all the luck you can get at this point.
Reply to this comment
by pkbptw May 23, 2008 11:02 AM PDT
Note to everyone...the alarm clock already exists its called IHome and the remote already exists its called Apple TV. I would love a digital frame that has the ability to access my Iphoto so I don't have to ever change the pictures out. Just because something isn't as groundbreaking as the Ipod doesn't mean it isn't a good idea.
Reply to this comment
by James7777777 May 23, 2008 11:16 AM PDT
Digital photo frames will become a great product once the price of color eInk goes down. Of course apple will not have one as they are not developing the technology. The remove may be made, and I'm sure everyone will praise apple for the ingenious invention, though they have existed for MCE for many years now, full touch screen and all.
Reply to this comment
by nbvail May 23, 2008 11:29 AM PDT
Amazing, the truth is the Newton was ahead of its time and that Jobs was not at Apple, now we have the iPHONE which ends all discussion on handhelds, people now have greater expectations and are looking to the future to filled with amazing handheld computers, thanks to the iPHONE. As for the FRAME, I could stream photos to grandma from my DOT MAC account, to that I saw wow - where do I buy it.
Reply to this comment
by edmalloy May 23, 2008 11:29 AM PDT
Damn! I guess there are some people who just can't read. How anybody can construe this column as "Apple hating" is beyond me. If we think of Apple as perfect, what does that say about our thinking. Apple takes risks and makes mistakes (anybody old enough to remember the Lisa?, or the Newton?).
Reply to this comment
by Rob Menke May 23, 2008 12:15 PM PDT
I think the complaint is not about the content (Forrester's report) but about the title, definitely designed to be link-bait. Don even apologizes in the second paragraph -- "this is not meant to be an indictment of Apple" -- which prevents him from laying the responsibility for the title on an overzealous editor. In these days of linkrolling, I suppose it is necessary.

A less inflammatory title would have been along the lines of, "Sorry, Forrester, but even Apple can't make dumb ideas work."
by AdamMoore May 23, 2008 12:37 PM PDT
I enjoy how everyone rips into him, further proving the point.

Last I checked, opinion wasn't something to get verbally raped about, however, in the Apple world, if it doesn't start with "Mac" or "i" essentially you are from the degraded gene pool.

As for the people who say, "Why does C|NET allow them to post this ... " well, first...this is a blog, and second, I sometimes wonder why your own common sense allows you to post the same dribble about PCs.
Reply to this comment
 See all 65 Comments >>
advertisement

In the news now

Slowing expectations at a green-tech start-up

Six months ago, biofuels start-up Mascoma had the wind in its sails, as did the rest of the clean-tech sector. Now, the company is treading carefully and scaling back.


With JavaFX, Sun seeks new coders, new revenue

With the launch of JavaFX 1.0, Sun is trying to reclaim Java's strength as a foundation for rich Internet applications. But it's no longer the incumbent.


Tim Lincecum, motion capture star

San Francisco Giants pitcher, who won the Cy Young award last month, dons a motion capture suit for 2K Sports' Major League Baseball 2K9 video game.


Resource center from CNET News sponsors
Business. Ready.
Sony VAIO® Professional PCs.

Click Here!
A new grade in mobility demands a new kind of notebook. And Sony delivers.Tough, portable and featuring up to 7.5 hours of battery life! VAIO® Professional notebooks are built for business. Learn more.

Click Here!
Built tough for business.

Learn more about the rigorous quality testing Sony puts its notebooks through.

Protect your investment.

Find out why VAIO® tech support recently won a Laptop Editors' Choice Award, July 2008.

Long battery life.

Up to 7.5 hours of battery life! See how VAIO® PCs will keep you productive longer when on the road.

Travel light

Check out our ultraportable line-up, starting at 2.87 lbs.

PCs for every need.

Find out which VAIO® notebook is right for you.

About The Digital Home

Don Reisinger is a technology columnist who has covered everything from HDTVs to computers to Flowbee Haircut Systems. Besides his work with CNET, Don's work has been featured in a variety of other publications including PC World and a host of Ziff-Davis publications.

Don writes product reviews for InformationWeek and is a regular contributor to Processor Magazine. You can visit his personal site at DonReisinger.com or if you would like to email Don with questions or comments, drop him a line at CNETDigitalHome@gmail.com. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Digital Home topics

Subscribe to the Digital Home podcast

Have you ever wanted a no-nonsense discussion on what is really going with all the tech topics related to your Digital Home? If so, join Don Reisinger as he brings you the same biting commentary you've come to expect from his Digital Home blog in all its audio glory.

Subscribe to this podcast using an RSS reader other than iTunes

Subscribe to this podcast using iTunes

Don's links
Don's Facebook account
Don's Twitter feed
Don's Friendfeed account
Don's Google Reader account
Don's Last.FM account
Don's Pownce account
Don's Flickr account
advertisement
advertisement
Click Here

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right