• On MovieTome: Who is directing GOD OF WAR THE MOVIE?
April 18, 2008 9:09 AM PDT

A tech lover's call to arms

Posted by Don Reisinger
  • Font size
  • Print

For years, I've wanted to write this piece, but for one reason or another, I didn't think it was the right time to do it. But now, as I look at technology zealots like myself who have been forced to submit to the will of the vocal minority that has no idea what this industry is all about, I think it's time.

Whether it's lawmakers, the RIAA, MPAA, "family groups" or other misguided individuals, these people are taking the technology industry to task for everything it stands for and anything it does. Gone are the days of appreciation for what technology provides and here are the days of contempt.

Years ago, technology lovers were not-so-affectionately called geeks who had no idea what the real world looks like. These people were ostensibly scared of the opposite sex in high school, enjoyed tinkering with electronics on weekends and hardly ever played sports. But as those geeks created technologies that transcended industries, they suddenly gained respect and the pejorative has become a term of endearment in appreciation for the creature comforts those people created.

But now, a new group of people has emerged to confront the tech lovers all over the world and stop them from being able to do what they want with the technology they own. And while many have tried to confront them on an individual basis, it has not worked. And it's for that reason that we must all come together and fight the ridiculous impositions brought upon us.

How many times must we hear that video games cause violence before we stand up together and stop the spewing of inaccurate ideas? How many times must we listen to the RIAA tell us that college students are the root of all evil as it pertains to piracy before we tell the organization that it's wrong? How many times must we listen to public interest groups allow families to get off the hook instead of blaming them when "security concerns" are revealed to the public before we tell them the truth? How many times must we listen to people who have no knowledge of the technology industry restate the misguided ramblings of lawmakers before we vote for change?

These questions have yet to be answered. Sure, some of us have ensured that we continue to inform tech lovers from all across the globe about what's really going on in the industry, but none of us -- journalists and readers -- have stood together to confront the beast that continues to grow each day.

Everyday when I wake up, I'm constantly reminded by how limited we are in our rights with technology. Why are women forced to pay ridiculous sums of cash for stealing 20 songs? Why are ten-year old children forced into a deposition that the plaintiff hopes will yield even more cash for a misguided cause? Why are college students blamed for piracy when huge cartels overseas are allowed to run amok? Why can companies charge too much for too little and get away with it? Why am I paying for 10mbps service when I only get 2mbps?

According to GamePolitics.com, an Arizona bill that was passed in the state's House of Representatives last month "would make content producers, publishers and distributors liable for monetary damages if any written, audio, visual or digital material from which they profited was judged to have been "dangerous" or obscene and motivated someone to commit a felony or an act of terrorism."

The ambiguity of that bill is indicative of many of the laws enacted by lawmakers all over the country. Instead of forcing people to be responsible for their own actions, lawmakers have seen it fit to embrace a policy that makes those who provide technology to individuals the lawbreakers. Ironically (or maybe not), that doesn't happen in any other industry. In other, more political, industries, the companies win out, but in the technology business, we're expected to suffer.

Of course, the plight of the technology industry goes far beyond video games. Each day, we're told that what we really want to do is wrong. You want to download music? Nope, you should be paying a ridiculous premium on CDs. You plan on ripping a DVD you own onto your computer? Don't even think about it. You're paying for faster speeds than you really get? Oh well. You're forced to pay $175 to get out a cell phone contract? Tough luck.

Some have said that it'll eventually get better when the younger generation assumes positions of power and I agree with that. But who really wants to wait that long? Why has the entire technology industry rolled over in the face of lawmakers and misguided organizations for no good reason?

Enough is enough.

I think it's time that every person who truly cares about the future of the technology industry and their own well-being stands up and rights the injustices being forced upon each and every one of us. We shouldn't be forced into specific arrangements that promise more than they provide and we surely shouldn't wait in anxious anticipation of what could be.

For what it's worth, I call on all journalists, readers and companies to forego their apathy and do what they can to stand together and fight the ridiculous notion that technology should be throttled back for fear of its inability to adapt to the expectations of the Old Guard.

If nothing else, technology is the beacon of hope in these times of economic and socio-political tumult and we should do what we can to ensure that misguided individuals and lawmakers alike understand and fully appreciate the value and importance of technology.

Don Reisinger is a technology columnist who has written about everything from HDTVs to computers to Flowbee Haircut Systems. Don is a member of the CNET Blog Network, and posts at The Digital Home. He is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.

Recent posts from The Digital Home
Should we stop the sale of used video games?
Bat and ball replaced by Web and games?
Why won't Sony or Microsoft admit Nintendo is a competitor?
Why I'm shopping on Black Friday this year
The Digital Home Video: Why you should use Chrome
The Digital Home 42: Should you shop on eBay?
Should parents police their children more aggressively?
The Digital Home Video: Violent video games don't cause violence!
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 30 comments
by SRobertRoberts April 18, 2008 9:18 AM PDT
It's a start, but more than just a call to arms is needed. There needs to be some form of organization (even if it's just a wiki and a mailing list), otherwise it'll just be viewed as a few lone crackpots writing letters.
Reply to this comment
by RobinQueens April 18, 2008 9:35 AM PDT
I am not a journalist , so there is only so much I can do. but I give you major kudos for bringing a focused light on the topic. lead the way don, I support your endeavor!
Reply to this comment
by hfjacinto April 18, 2008 10:44 AM PDT
I say the only people we have to blame are ourselves, if we didn't elect the people into power we wouldn't have created these dumb laws. We have granted inc's more power than people have and since the management is imunne from decisions they make, why not screw the average joe. The issue is more than just technology rights, the companies now control the govemernt and the laws are written to protect companies. How can a drug company sell a pill for $100 when it costs $1 to manufacture and why will the drug company fight to protect its patent when a generic manufactures the same pill. I know a company has a legal right to recoup its intial investment and research and still earn a profit, but with ceo earning $25M+ and the average joe not getting any raises when is too much profit enough?
Reply to this comment
by JustANetizen April 18, 2008 10:29 PM PDT
You're absolutely right. The problem is simply that the balance (of power, money, whatever) got lost. I know, it never really existed, but in the past there was at least some balance between rights of the corporations and of the country versus the rights of the individual. Right now, megacorps like the RIAA, the MPAA and others have seen an opening, an area where lawmakers have no profound understanding and where no consensus in society exists about how to handle things there, and they push hard to get their foot in before anyone gets to their senses. It has always been like that - think Manchester Capitalism - those in power were always influenced first by those with money. And the average Joe always had to fight back, by forming unions or new political parties. Only then the balance of things will be restored. I think the "Pirate Party"-movement in europe is a good start, a political party that promotes freedom online and offline and free (as in beer) nonmaterial cultural goods.
by joebaker April 18, 2008 10:17 PM PDT
It is respect for our humanity that is at stake. They want to subjugate us and treat us like cattle. Walk in the dignity and humanity and demand respect as such. Joseph William Baker
Reply to this comment
by jaymz411 April 18, 2008 10:32 PM PDT
Why not a "Call to put your money where your mouth is"?

Join the only group that has been on the front lines battling these atrocities:
The Electronic Frontier Foundation
http://www.eff.org/support
Reply to this comment
by ssnape2 April 18, 2008 10:49 PM PDT
The only people to blame are ourselves? Since when have we been offered any real choice in political hacks we can vote for? Since when has most of the government that actually runs things even been subject to a vote? Even if we had been in charge somehow then we should be responsible enough to admit that we made a bad decision and act decisively to change it. The one thing we should never do and which cannot be forgiven is to simply whine that it is our fault and that therefore we should just accept what is going on. That is the path of utter apathy and lack of honesty.

Companies have no power of physical coercion. Only governments do. We did empower governments massively over way too many areas of our lives both explicitly and by not paying attention and demanding freedom from such coercion by countless busybodies (and worse) funded by money expropriated from us. Corporations are not your enemy, governments are. Governments screw everyone and utterly bankrupt the country to boot. Save the populist crap. Government loves it. It keeps you blaming everyone and everything but the jackbooted thug mashing your face into the dirt.
Reply to this comment
by kombipom April 19, 2008 1:48 AM PDT
"companies have no power of physical coercion"... Presumably setting a band of out of control lawyers on people doesn't count? Bribing politicians to impose or block laws against the best interests of the public? Governments are far from perfect but their major flaw at present seems to be that they are in the pockets of large corporations and not afraid of a timid and apathetic electorate.
by pizzcaj April 24, 2008 3:03 PM PDT
You're so right, ssnape2. That's why I voted for Pat Buchanan during the 1990's and Ron Paul if he's on the ballot this November. I knew Buchanan was the real deal after winning the New Hampshire primary back in 1996 and seeing how the so-called Republican Party viciously demonized him because they knew that he would really carry out what they "promised" in their campaigns.
by zwithapggb April 18, 2008 11:02 PM PDT
You mean, like blaming guns and law abiding gun owners for what criminals do with guns? Oh wait, I bet you and the rest of the /. and Digg crowd think we cling to those because we are disenfranchized (as opposed to preferring to use the right tool: a gun, for the job of dispatching an assailant: as opposed to a cell phone; when all the cops who you call will be able to do when they get there 20 minutes to an hour later is call CSI and clean up your entrails).
What you're seeing is luddism, pure and simple. It's a natural reaction to a world that has changed faster than people can handle it. It's part of the same reflex that makes people susceptible to Al Gore's politically correct untruths, or to the Eden meme in general, and its modern day incarnation: Environmentalism.
Take comfort in the fact that, despite the rabble and politicos, the industrialists did fine, and their descendants are still wealthy. Expect the same for our kind, and ignore the hoi polloi. "The dogs may bark, but the caravan still passes."
Reply to this comment
by _Marvin_ April 19, 2008 1:04 AM PDT
I totally agree with Don and also SRobertRoberts. Since it's up do us we gotta do something. I for one did so on a smaller scale by starting my own http://blog.techflaws.org to denoucne greedy corporations that fob us with flawed products. If you're up to something on a larger scale just let me know.
Reply to this comment
by LightKnight69 April 19, 2008 2:19 AM PDT
Metoo! I think it is a FANTASTIC idea and a worthy cause you are calling to arms for.

If it is to become action, you/we need somewhere to focus our attention. Already a member of www.eff.org, I would enjoy a more interactive place to gather.

Don, would you care to lead the way or point to a common place to gather, rather than each of us pointing this way and that - leading to dilution of your excellent focus?

All these domains are available: techloverscalltoarms tech-lovers-call-to-arms techcalltoarms tech-call-to-arms tlcta tcta (.org, .com, .net). Or suggest an already existing net location...

Peter
Reply to this comment
by brunolowagie April 19, 2008 3:22 AM PDT
We need to change the economy.
We can use this by taking away misconceptions about open source, open content, open everything. Google for 'Voluntary Economies' to find out more about it. Last Thursday I convinced an audience of 83 attendees (mainly representatives of governmental administrations) of my ideals.
Read: http://www.lowagie.com/maand.php?year=2008&month=4#809
I know it's an utopia, but if only we could get halfway towards that utopia, the world could be a better place.
Reply to this comment
by PaulSinnett April 19, 2008 3:29 AM PDT
You are somewhat late to the party. http://www.eff.org/ is exactly what you are asking for.
Reply to this comment
by gefferyjones April 19, 2008 4:36 AM PDT
I have worked in the tech industry for longer than I would like to think about. It has changed so much from the days when, I think, we felt we were doing something new, exciting and cutting edge. It is about time the people who brought the world the ability to have an mp3 player, tivo, laptops that fit into a backpack and all the other things we enjoy have a bit of a say. If something like the EFF, as listed in an earlier post, is not what you want to do, at least educate those around you.
Reply to this comment
by geoffdaily April 19, 2008 7:48 AM PDT
We don't just need a call to arms to unite people against losing their technological freedoms, we also need to recognize that more work needs to be done to make technology more accessible to the 95% of the world that isn't tech savvy.

We can't just introduce new technology and expect the entire order of things to make way and accommodate these new possibilities.

We must be cognizant of how these new possibilities can integrate into what already exists, can nudge the order in a new direction, and can make things better and easier rather than more complicated.

I can't wait to see what's going to happen once the creative energy of our tech elite gets more focused on solving the real-world problems of the masses through technology and the Internet rather than on merely catering to a limited crowd of early adopters.

www.app-rising.com
Reply to this comment
by DMerriman April 19, 2008 8:06 AM PDT
This shouldn't be a surprise, really. If you allow a bunch of people that neither comprehend the technology nor have the skills to use it properly, the vast majority of them are going to blame it for errors that it isn't responsible for.
It never ceases to amaze me the number of people that wouldn't DREAM of jumping in a car and driving it without learning how to use it first are willing to do much the same thing with computers and the like.
Reply to this comment
by TommyLeeT April 19, 2008 8:53 AM PDT
You are basically echoing what Stallman said 30 years ago...
Reply to this comment
by trm96 April 19, 2008 9:35 AM PDT
Very good article! You bring up a lot of good points. It's a shame that the tech people (such as myself) created the technology but these other bastards get to say what we can do with the technology that would not even be here with out us. It makes me very mad to see how these people are trying to tell us what to do with OUR technology. My article here: http://trm96.com/blog/http://trm96.com/blog/cnet-writer-a-call-to-arms/
Reply to this comment
by trm96 April 19, 2008 9:36 AM PDT
that should be: http://trm96.com/blog/cnet-writer-a-call-to-arms/
by nothankscnet April 19, 2008 10:41 AM PDT
Great idea. But bear in mind the cell plan complaint is false. You're not paying for early termination, you're paying for the "free" phone they gave you. If you don't want the fee, then buy your own phone before subscribing.
Reply to this comment
by jimrap April 19, 2008 3:26 PM PDT
Great column Don. I've talked about this in the past and what tech users really need is a lobbying organization. If we had our own version of the NRA we would be able to fight against bad laws and also fight for laws that would help tech users (such as fair use and privacy rights).
Reply to this comment
by alizardx April 19, 2008 5:47 PM PDT
so start a successful high-tech user PAC.

When we can pool our money to buy our own politicians, our problems will get taken seriously. $50K to Hillary a few years ago and her unbelievable stories would involve Boss level on popular video games, not video game EVIL!!!
Reply to this comment
by malconium April 20, 2008 10:11 AM PDT
I believe this is the best article I have seen on this subject. I think that what needs to be done is every person in the world that cares about their mp3 player or their games, or anything else related to tech, needs to educate themselves and pass it on. It is time that we all rise up as one and beat down the bastard child that is our gov't. Things have finally reached a point that if we don't our souls will burn with those that rule us. We allow this evil to continue. NO MORE I SAY. RISE UP. STAND AGAINST. AND DON'T BOW DOWN!!!!!!!
Reply to this comment
 See all 30 Comments >>
advertisement

In the news now

Slowing expectations at a green-tech start-up

Six months ago, biofuels start-up Mascoma had the wind in its sails, as did the rest of the clean-tech sector. Now, the company is treading carefully and scaling back.


With JavaFX, Sun seeks new coders, new revenue

With the launch of JavaFX 1.0, Sun is trying to reclaim Java's strength as a foundation for rich Internet applications. But it's no longer the incumbent.


Tim Lincecum, motion capture star

San Francisco Giants pitcher, who won the Cy Young award last month, dons a motion capture suit for 2K Sports' Major League Baseball 2K9 video game.


Resource center from CNET News sponsors
Business. Ready.
Sony VAIO® Professional PCs.

Click Here!
A new grade in mobility demands a new kind of notebook. And Sony delivers.Tough, portable and featuring up to 7.5 hours of battery life! VAIO® Professional notebooks are built for business. Learn more.

Click Here!
Built tough for business.

Learn more about the rigorous quality testing Sony puts its notebooks through.

Protect your investment.

Find out why VAIO® tech support recently won a Laptop Editors' Choice Award, July 2008.

Long battery life.

Up to 7.5 hours of battery life! See how VAIO® PCs will keep you productive longer when on the road.

Travel light

Check out our ultraportable line-up, starting at 2.87 lbs.

PCs for every need.

Find out which VAIO® notebook is right for you.

About The Digital Home

Don Reisinger is a technology columnist who has covered everything from HDTVs to computers to Flowbee Haircut Systems. Besides his work with CNET, Don's work has been featured in a variety of other publications including PC World and a host of Ziff-Davis publications.

Don writes product reviews for InformationWeek and is a regular contributor to Processor Magazine. You can visit his personal site at DonReisinger.com or if you would like to email Don with questions or comments, drop him a line at CNETDigitalHome@gmail.com. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Digital Home topics

Subscribe to the Digital Home podcast

Have you ever wanted a no-nonsense discussion on what is really going with all the tech topics related to your Digital Home? If so, join Don Reisinger as he brings you the same biting commentary you've come to expect from his Digital Home blog in all its audio glory.

Subscribe to this podcast using an RSS reader other than iTunes

Subscribe to this podcast using iTunes

Don's links
Don's Facebook account
Don's Twitter feed
Don's Friendfeed account
Don's Google Reader account
Don's Last.FM account
Don's Pownce account
Don's Flickr account
advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right