Here at CNET we love to laud the greatest products. It's more fun to talk about the best than about the seriously disappointing. But in a nod to equal time, we looked back over the past year and collected the 10 products that got the worst ratings of the year. None of them scored above 4. All of them hurt the hearts of our reviewers. If for no other reason than to provide balance (and some schadenfreude), here are the top 10 worst products of the year.
It's always disappointing when you pay very little for a product only to have it break or operate poorly. But it's almost insulting to pay quite a lot for a product and have it let you down as much as this one does. This Kreisen TV has come down in price since we first reviewed it, but not enough. It's one of the few products that actually turned on and ran that still got the 'poor' rating.
"Dude, you're getting a Dell" is usually a good thing--but not with this TV. Granted, it had a bargain price, but it hardly did anything other TVs do. Every class has a slacker, and this one was Dell's underachiever. Dell has wisely stopped selling this clunker.
What if Apple had issued the Shuffle as a 128MB player that didn't support anything but MP3 and--oh, yeah--couldn't shuffle? You'd get the iRock 930 MP3ez. You can expand the iRock with an SD card. But that will cost you as much as or more than the player itself. In fact, the only really good thing about this player is the sub-$50 price.
Wireless headphones over which you can't hear anything are useless. Anyone who has used an FM transmitter with an iPod understands the unreliability of FM transmission. Someone should have informed Aerielle. I'm sure these headphones could sound good. You'd just have to move to the Moon, away from all FM transmissions, to be sure.
Do you want to make CD labels with your photo software? What's that, you say? That's the only thing you'd ever want to do with your photo software? Great! PhotoSuite 7 is just fine for you. It's also good for driving usability experts to suicide.
This one may be unfair. After all, a waterproof case for your iPod should keep the iPod dry, and this does. Bone dry. Not a drop of water touched our iPod. We couldn't really listen to or control the iPod, but it was dry as a desert. Yep.
The Fossil Wrist PDA started off with so much promise. It's a watch that's Mac compatible, runs a Palm OS, and doesn't require a service fee. Unfortunately, you need a magnifying glass to see the display elements, and the stylus is a joke--and not a very funny one. If you can't use something, it doesn't matter what it's made of. It is gorgeous, though.
Let's imagine that you're a subscriber to Real's Rhapsody service who occasionally wants to stream video, audio, and only Rhapsody radio stations from the Internet to your DVD player. If you don't mind the player deciding when it's in the mood to connect to the network, you're all set.
In theory, a Wi-Fi print server is just the ticket. In theory, you plug it into your printer, it connects to your home Wi-Fi network, and you can print from any device on the network. In theory, you don't have bald patches on your head from the frustration caused by the setup process. In theory, WPA is a pretty common security option that every Wi-Fi device should support. In theory.
Here's another product that came out of the gate with a lot of promise. The Toshiba Satellite can play CDs without booting, has external Wi-Fi and volume controls, and is pretty lightweight. What's that? I can't hear you? I just turned the thing on, and I can't hear you over the fan! Oh, wait--that's better. The battery just died.