Version: 2008
  • On TechRepublic: 10 cool USB flash drive tricks
HOLIDAY SHOPPING Q&A: Get the answers to your gift-buying questions
Holiday Shopping Q&A: Get the answers to your gift-buying questions
Best HDTV image quality
(December 20, 2004)
Q If there were no space restrictions (we'll worry about money later), which delivers the best image: direct-view HDTV, rear-projection HDTV, plasma TV, LCD flat panels, or analog TV?
Submitted by: Wayne Daniels, via e-mail
David Katzmaier
David Katzmaier
Senior editor,
CNET Reviews
If money and space are not an obstacle, three-tube CRT projectors, followed closely by three-chip DLP projectors, provide the best images. These cost tens of thousands of dollars and usually require a dedicated screening room.

Opinions on real-world HDTVs vary among experts, but most would probably agree that the best consumer direct-view CRT tubes provide the most consistently great images of the bunch. Among larger-screen sets, the best plasmas are the champs to my eye (although plasma picture quality varies greatly between makes), followed closely by LCD microdisplays (chip-based rear-projection), which in my opinion beat DLP and the rest by a nose because they don't exhibit rainbow effects. Again, there is lots of variation between makes, and many people don't notice rainbows with DLP.

That could change with the introduction of yet more new microdisplay television technology, which also includes DLP and LCoS and its variants. Flat-panel LCDs are also getting better rapidly, but they're not yet at the level of the others. Rear-projection CRTs and analog direct-view sets make up the bottom end of the scale.



MORE RESOURCES
TV buying guide
Editors' top TVs
HDTV World
Discuss TVs

Got a holiday question?
Submit it here!
Get more shopping help!
Watch our previously recorded Holiday Help Desk segments to get answers to your holiday buying questions.
advertisement
Holiday shopping Q&A by topic
MOST-RECENT QUESTIONS
Camcorders
Low-light camcorder  Answered by Lori Grunin
Best prosumer camcorder  Answered by Lori Grunin


Cell phones
Prepaid cell phones  Answered by Kent German


Desktops
Best PC for graphic design  Answered by Matt Elliott
Best computer DVR  Answered by Matt Elliott
Budget beginner PC  Answered by Matt Elliott
New PC for son  Answered by Matt Elliott


Digital cameras
Best camera for a teenager  Answered by Lori Grunin
Cameras for indoor use  Answered by Aimee Baldridge
Fast cameras  Answered by Lori Grunin
Back up photos while traveling  Answered by Aimee Baldridge


Digital music
Stream music from Windows  Answered by James Kim
iPod vs. HP iPod  Answered by James Kim
Best MP3 player for kids  Answered by James Kim
Best car audio  Answered by Brian Cooley
MP3 player with remote  Answered by James Kim
CD changer with MP3  Answered by Jasmine France
Where to purchase MP3s  Answered by James Kim
Who can challenge the iPod?  Answered by James Kim


Games and gear
Speakers for gamers  Answered by Matt Elliott
Lightweight gaming laptops  Answered by Justin Jaffe
Best gaming consoles  Answered by John Falcone
Gaming PC  Answered by Rich Brown


Handhelds
Which PDA should I ask for?  Answered by Bonnie Cha
Can you still get e-books?  Answered by Bonnie Cha


Home audio
Easy home theater setup  Answered by David Katzmaier
Best cheap wireless headphones  Answered by David Carnoy
Sports on satellite radio  Answered by John Falcone


Home video
Put VHS tapes onto DVD  Answered by John Falcone
Burn slides to DVD  Answered by Felisa Yang
Best DVD player for parents  Answered by John Falcone
DVD recorders  Answered by David Katzmaier


Monitors
Monitor for TV  Answered by Felisa Yang


Notebooks
Which laptop should I ask for?  Answered by Justin Jaffe
Lightweight gaming laptops  Answered by Justin Jaffe
Laptop TV  Answered by Rich Brown
Best laptop for students  Answered by Justin Jaffe


Shopping
Are online prices for real?  Answered by David Katzmaier
Best time to buy a PC  Answered by Janice Chen
Avoid buyer's remorse  Answered by Janice Chen


Software
Can I make my own holiday cards?  Answered by Robert Vamosi
Encyclopedia as a gift  Answered by Robert Vamosi
Stop bad programs  Answered by Robert Vamosi


Televisions
Built-in HDTV tuner?  Answered by David Carnoy
HDTV cables  Answered by David Katzmaier
HDTV TiVo  Answered by John Falcone
Best HDTV image quality  Answered by David Katzmaier